Your best bet, so to speak, is still Phil Steele’s College Football Preview. Sure he’s heavy on the self-promotion and the tiny font. But it really is the best of the bunch overall. Here’s the site to go to for reviews of the magazines themselves for overall evaluation.
The one thing consistent in all of them is the last two teams in the Big East. All of them pick Cinci for 7th and Syracuse for 8th in the Big East. Amazingly, there is at least one mag that doesn’t pick WVU for 1st.