Sorry. I can’t help myself.
So many topics. Khem Birch leaving still swirls. The next coach for football. Todd Graham leftovers. Oh, and there happens to be a basketball game tonight. And hey, the Beef O’Brady Bowl is tonight that features an FIU team coached by Mario Cristobal. No winter break around here.
There’s nothing about Birch’s departure that makes me feel good. Pitt will be fine, but you do have to worry about the kid. People really seem to like him, but not the people he has let surround him.
“Khem is a great kid,” Hurd said. “This situation is painting him as something he is not. The problem is he is being led down a road by so-called advisors. It’s going to end poorly for Khem, and that is sad for me because I care about the kid. This is not going to end well for him.”
…
“If you asked me last year at this time I would have told you Pitt was the perfect place for him,” Hurd said. “If you ask me today I would tell you Pitt is the perfect place for him. I don’t know that this was his decision. Khem is an emotional person. My experience with Khem is that sometimes he can paint himself into a corner, and he didn’t know how to get out of it. This isn’t a situation where Jamie doesn’t like the kid. He likes him.”
This echoes the comments Chris Dokish made when Birch was first rumored to be bailing.
Originally, Birch was supposed to play one more season of prep school and be part of Pitt’s 2012 class — good god, that would have been the #1 class with Birch, Adams and Robinson. Birch, though, made a sudden decision, though, to reclassify for 2011. Considering all the talk about Birch being the most highly touted Pitt recruit since Brian Shorter, there was no shortage of one-and-done talk. My theory at the time was that Birch and his people were concerned that after the NBA lockout that was coming, the draft rules were going to be changed again to make it a two-year wait. So, getting Birch in early would solve that problem.
There were some rumors put out there that Birch was homesick. Keep in mind that Birch went to a bunch of high schools in 5 years including boarding/prep school at ND Prep. So that seemed questionable. Even more so when the transfer rumors are Mizzou or New Mexico State.
Pitt, however, might not release him to Missouri. I don’t have any knowledge, just a possible reason. Pitt is almost certainly in the Big East through 2012-13 season. Missouri is already going to the SEC for 2012. There just happens to be that whole SEC/Big East Challenge. That possible meeting might be enough to keep him from transferring to any SEC school. We will see about that part.
No one thinks Birch is making a smart decision. Whether it is for his own interests or because he just got frustrated like an increasing number of mid-year transfer players.
Still, Birch’s shocking decision to leave midway through his freshman year is on pace with the larger defects that have plagued college basketball’s culture over the last decade. Players are routinely shepherded through a grassroots system that caters to their every need, where there’s always another high school or AAU team ready to accept them at the first sign of adversity. No wonder so many of them bail on college. For the first time in their lives, they’re being held accountable. And they can’t handle it.
Yes, there are good reasons to change schools, and coaches are often at fault for over-promising during the recruiting process. But leaving mid-semester of your freshman year? When you’re starting? Former Pitt guard Brad Wannamaker said it best on Twitter after Birch announced his decision: “Guess everybody ain’t built for tough coaching and competing for minutes.”
Birch’s foolish move is the latest example of how the rush to the NBA can warp the minds of young players and, especially, the adults who are in their ears. “If you become a senior in college, in many regards you’re seen as a failure. That’s the starting point,” Arizona coach Sean Miller says. “If things aren’t going according to that timeline, if there’s any type of learning curve or process or hardship or obstacles, then many times the answer becomes, I’ve got to change my environment.”
Again, nothing is clear as to why Birch is transferring. Certainly no one was labeling him a bust. Some Pitt fans wanted him to have more playing time, but even last spring recruiting people were saying he was going to need more time:
Birch is a talented, quiet young man with a big smile. The physical tools are there to be a very good prospect, however, he’s not ready to dominate in the Big East for Pittsburgh next season. He’s more of a prospect than producer at this very moment and that’s a big delineation because of the expectations that he’ll bring to Pitt’s team, especially since he’s Jamie Dixon’s second McDonald’s All-American.
I’m quite sure Dixon is thrilled to have Birch, but he probably understands that his new center is not Jared Sullinger; he’s not wired up that way. Birch needs strength, which will add to his confidence, especially on offense. Next year, as a freshman, expect him to give Pitt a presence as a shot blocker, a big who can run the floor and as he develops in the program, his offensive and rebounding numbers will ascend. Just don’t expect him to sport the Superman cape right from the start.
Give Dave Telep for nailing that one. Except for the whole transferring thing.
One thing is certain, the players on Pitt — past and present — weren’t lining up behind Birch. Talib Zanna got some attention in the papers and offered a rather candid assessment of Birch in practices.
Zanna, a 6-foot-9, 230-pound redshirt sophomore, said it took him a full year to get used to the rough practices and trash-talking that takes place during a typical Pitt practice. Zanna eventually adjusted and is now giving it in practice — physically and verbally — as much as the other player.
“We know coach [Jamie] Dixon is a tough coach to play for,” Zanna said. “You have to come in and give all you got every day. When I came in it was kind of tough. Everybody was bigger than me. I was taller, but they were all bigger and stronger than me. In practice, they would push you around and talk all kinds of stuff. It was frustrating.
“I just had to get in the weight room and get stronger and get to their level. Once you’re in that level you have that confidence to challenge whoever is trying to bully you. Not bully you but try to push you around.”
Zanna saw that same frustration with Birch. Pitt’s practices brought Birch to tears on more than one occasion, Zanna said. He described how a hand injury brought Birch to tears.
“His wrist and hands were banged up,” Zanna said. “He banged it like three times in a row. There was a lot of pain. He couldn’t sustain the pain so he just had to cry. I don’t even know if I would say it was crying, but if you looked at his face it looked like he was crying. This program might have been too tough for him. I think that’s why he left.”
Zanna said he never spoke to Birch about attempting to stick it out. Birch was a bit of a loner and did not hang out with many others on the team.
“It’s a real shame,” Zanna said. “He made Coach Dixon look bad. That was up to him. It was his own decision. If he wanted to move on because he wanted more playing time that was up to him. We just have to move on and let him do his stuff. We’ll be fine without him, or with him.”
There is no secret that Pitt has tough practices. Plenty of coaches do it that way. Tom Izzo is one of the most well-known practioners of the physical practices. When you see how few players have transferred out of Pitt (and Michigan State for that matter) you realize how the players brought in actually embrace the practices. Grasp what it is doing for them.
Birch is still going to need the strength and be able to handle physical play — no matter where he ends up. Sadly, he and his “advisors,” have set Birch back on getting to that point.
Sad story for Birch..this may completely set him back in his quest to become pro.
Kid couldn’t hang with the big dogs…and he wasnt even bangin’ bodies with Gary McGhee or Big Juan Blair.
put that into perspective…im sorry, but what a effing pussy.
Jamie Dixon built the roster around Birch…dropped a few kids for Birch and then he turns his back on Jamie?
Super Selfish!!!!
WTF?!?!?!
It appears Khem couldn’t hack being knocked around in practice and not having his ego stroked by being told he’s the best thing since sliced bread every day.
Who advises somebody to pack it in and run home after 5 months? Geez, I wouldn’t let my 6 year old daughter quit half way thru a rec soccer season.
Montreal’s Gift my A$$
Hopefully Jamie can turn that scholarship around for one of the uncommitted recruits of 2012.
“If you can’t stand the heat, get out of the kitchen.”
Birch would have benefitted by gutting it out, he would have gotten stronger and improved his game.
He hurt himself by leaving and he hurt the team by reclasifiying and replacing another player who could have helped.
Its infuriating that “advisors” are misleading Birch about what’s best for him. Taking advantage of an emotional and suggestible 19yr old is criminal. Its disillusioning because this is not uncommon and in some ways an institutional problem. Ultimately I’m proud that our players were tough on Birch cuz that’s how players get better and that the program isn’t breaking its back trying to get the kid back so the other guys know its never about one kid. Proud mostly that the current and past players seem to totally buy in to Dixon’s program and defend it.
I’d still like to see the kid back at Pitt soon when he comes to his sense. But though he likely wont return, this could galvanize the team giving them (esp Taylor) motivation to show they’re in the right program and that they made the right decisions. (boy, i hope that’s what happens….)
Yes, Bond got the raw deal, but Jamie was forced to make some choice. Quite frankly I don’t know any coach that would have turned away a top 5 recruit. As I said, Jamie could have chosen to take away a scholarship from someone on the roster but that would have been the much more classless way to go.
I just don’t buy the karma thing on Jamie for how things went down.
also, I think Birch changing his mind and coming a year early, put Jamie Dixon in a very difficult spot. I had read about Jaylen Bond and thought he would fit in well. We lose on both counts.
or Anthony Bennett a 5 star they both still have PITT on there list.
and if we land one of them we move up to the number 1 class in the USA for 2012 from the number 5 class that is the bright side.
Dominus Cimentarius
vertas et virtus
Whether he could have done this in a more classless way doesn’t change that a commitment was broken.
And I agree that most coaches, and we as fans (at least at the time), would support bringing in Birch over Bond…but it is still a broken commitment to a guy he recruited and made a promise to.
It would be interesting to know if Jamie felt shady in asking Bond to wait a year and how much pressure he felt from Birch’s advisors in making that decision…and whether he would make the same decision in regard to future recruits.
Once again, I think Jamie is the man…but I thought this angle was interesting.
Last two games he’s gone for Double Doubles I believe. However as I stated before, Birch had a double/double in his very first collegiate start and nearly had one in his 2nd collegiate start.
Sounds like our players were too gangsta for him.
Being from Montreal, maybe that crap doesn’t go on up there. Zanna seemed to state that in so many words. I can’t remember now, did Birch have his body plastered with tattoo’s and gang symbols?
Next question, how is a white guy from New Zealand going to fit in with our current makeup of playa’s ??
link to thevikingweaponsstore.com
For as soon as Birch was gone, one Dante Taylor, who was performing a lot better with the obvious push by Birch, resorted back to one Sleepy Taylor.
What 2 points and a 3 rebounds against a MEAC team. So that would be 3 players who we lose on this transaction. Me don’t like. haha
on the issue of “gangsta” — Steven Adams has a SERIOUSLY badass tattoo and perfect for his new crew
But I mean how gangsta does it get in New Zealand?
I’m not going to say Birch is a bad kid. I don’t know if that is true. I will say that he had a lot of talent. I will also say that this decision is completely bizarre and does him no good. If he didn’t like it at Pitt, then he would have been better off leaving at the end of the year for another school or the NBA.
Maybe his handlers didn’t want him to be overshadowed by Steve Adams next year. This is very stupid because one shouldn’t count their chickens before they hatch (Adams isn’t here yet). Additionally, wouldn’t Adams playing well only help Birch if he was at the 4. Just a completely stupid decision.
I’m much more reassured now.
BTW, nice play on words Chas.
I thought the team Khemistry didn’t look quite right! 🙂
Bottom line is that Bond left on his own. Dixon didn’t make him leave.
Another week, another transfer. This time Pittsburgh big man Khem Birch (Top 100 Rank: 82) decided to bolt despite starting every game this season and seeing meaningful minutes. Birch wasn’t a major scoring option for Pittsburgh but he averaged 5.5 rpg in just 15 mpg. Scouts were noticing his play and had he stayed at Pitt one more year, he had a very good shot at getting drafted. Now? Let’s just say the history of prospects transferring to another school is pretty depressing from an NBA draft perspective. Maybe Birch had a good reason to leave … but it certainly won’t help his draft stock.
-Chad Ford, ESPN NBA Draft Expert
… but I was strictly talking about the Panther claw tattoo, which is seriously badass
Bottom line is that Bond was offered a 2011 scholarship first, there was a two way commitment and then when Birch reclassified, there were too many scholarships issued for 2011 and he got pushed out.
Ask yourself this: If Bond was 2012 and Birch 2011, would Dixon accept Bond for 2011 if he reclassified to 2011? I don’t think so.
A commitment was broken in favor of making the bigger fish happy…Jamie is the man, but he did something shady imo to help the program…unfortunately, it backfired.
.
All I can think is that either:
— He’s really just an mercurial, emotional kid who isn’t ready for elite D1 hoops, OR
— his advisors are selfishly pushing to to another school they already have in mind. While khem doesn’t benefit from this the future school might. But for most high-level programs, it doesn’t make sense either. The ones it makes sense for are those who think they’re going to lose a load of talent after this year (Oh St, UK, UNC, etc) or a school that is trying to breakthrough or make a big comeback in hoops (N Mex St and Mizzou make sense). You would htink Mizzou knows by now better than to do anything that sniffs of impropriety, but I know that they are desperate to be a relevant basketball program again and looking to raise their profile in the conference realignment saga.
N Mex St has nothing to lose really being in the WAC. Landing Birch could win them their conference and get them in the Tourny, raise their profile in light of all the conference realignment.
I know its stretch to come up with motives and reasons. But Idunno, this is just a really weird decision.
I disagree. Bond was not pushed out. He left on his own. Epps would have been pushed out for Bond. That may be “shady”, but this isn’t the YMCA. Coach Dixon has to make decisions that affect a real athletic department. His decision would have been to encourage Mr. Epps to leave.
I think if the roles were reversed (Bond 2012, Birch 2011), Dixon would tell Bond that his 2011 quota has been met, he has made commitments to the 2011 kids which he won’t break and to go to prep school for 2011.
In any case, good debate. We’ll have to disagree on this one.
I do agree w/ you on Zanna.
@EMEL, only you could bring up “Vikings Mace”, and make it fit. Nice work.
I’ve always wanted one of those things. Get those crazy catalogs, knife catalogs and such, they always have that stuff in them.
Someday, for the wall!!